There are roughly 10,000 college football players in EA Sports College Football 27. Then there's Gunner Stockton — a Heisman Trophy contender, a fourth-quarter closer who once went 12-for-12 against a top-five opponent, the starting quarterback of a program that has won back-to-back SEC titles — who apparently decided to sit this one out.
When EA Sports released its player ratings database ahead of College Football 27's July 9 launch, two names jumped off the page for their absence rather than their numbers: Georgia quarterback Gunner Stockton and Georgia Tech running back Justice Haynes. Neither player appears in the game at launch, per reports from SleeperCFB and confirmed by the ratings database. Both were in College Football 25 and College Football 26. Both will be among the most talked-about players in college football this fall. And right now, neither one exists in the virtual world their fans want to play in.
The internet, predictably, had thoughts.
How This Works — And Why It Matters
The opt-in system EA Sports uses is pretty straightforward in concept. Players receive an NIL licensing offer, agree to it, and their name, image, and likeness gets used in the game. The deal reportedly pays $600 and includes a copy of the game. For a chance to be immortalized on a national stage and get paid for it, the opt-in rate across FBS has historically been well above 85 percent. Most players say yes without a second thought.
Stockton and Haynes, for whatever reason, have not — at least not yet. The key word is yet. Neither player is permanently locked out. EA Sports has built roster updates into its post-launch infrastructure, meaning both can still complete the necessary paperwork and be patched into the game after release. The window hasn't closed. But for fans booting up CFB 27 on July 9, Georgia's starting quarterback won't be taking snaps under center, and Georgia Tech's most anticipated new arrival won't be in the backfield.
That stings in a way that's hard to quantify but easy to feel if you've ever tried to run a franchise with your team's actual roster.
The Stockton Factor
To understand why this hit differently than a typical opt-out, you have to understand what Gunner Stockton actually did in 2025.
In his first full season as Georgia's starter, Stockton completed nearly 70 percent of his passes for 2,894 yards, threw 24 touchdowns against just five interceptions, and added 462 rushing yards and 10 scores on the ground — the most rushing touchdowns among SEC quarterbacks. He led four fourth-quarter comebacks. He was the MVP of the SEC Championship Game. He finished seventh in Heisman voting. ESPN has him penciled in as a frontrunner for the 2026 Heisman race before a single snap of the new season has been played.
The man is the face of one of college football's most dominant programs. And he had an 82 rating in College Football 26, meaning EA already had a benchmark for who he is in the game. For him to not appear in the follow-up installment — even temporarily — is the kind of absence that makes franchise mode feel hollow for Georgia fans.
His fourth-quarter numbers were particularly absurd. Stockton completed 83.6 percent of his passes in the final period with seven touchdowns and zero interceptions in 2025. Against Ole Miss, he went 12-for-12 passing for 135 yards and three touchdowns, erasing a nine-point deficit in the fourth quarter alone. That performance made him the first quarterback to go 12-for-12 or better against an AP top-five opponent since Aaron Rodgers at Cal in 2004. These are the kinds of moments that make someone fun to be in a video game. The guy clutches up when it matters, and fans can't use him.
Justice Haynes Came Home For This
The Haynes piece adds its own layer of intrigue. The running back transferred to Georgia Tech this offseason after a standout — if injury-shortened — season at Michigan, where he rushed for 857 yards and 10 touchdowns in just seven games before a foot injury ended his year prematurely. The former four-star recruit is back in his home state of Georgia for his senior season, projected as a second-round pick in the 2027 NFL Draft, and widely expected to be the Yellow Jackets' lead back and one of the most electric players in the ACC in 2026.
Analysts have described Haynes as a back with outstanding contact balance, short-area burst, and the ability to make second-level defenders miss in ways that show up in the highlights more than the stat sheet. He was a third-team All-Big Ten selection before the injury. Georgia Tech fans who were excited to finally run someone dangerous out of the backfield are now staring at a depth chart in-game that doesn't include their most anticipated addition.
Like Stockton, Haynes appeared in the last two editions of the game. Like Stockton, his absence is more confusing than it is conspicuous because there's no stated reason — no public stance, no dramatic announcement, just a missing entry in a ratings database.
This Has Happened Before
It's worth noting that this situation isn't unprecedented. When EA Sports revived the College Football franchise with College Football 25 in 2024, the highest-profile opt-out was Texas quarterback Arch Manning — who, at the time, had barely played a college snap and was operating under a family-set rule that he wouldn't take NIL money until he was a starter. Manning opted out citing a desire to focus on football. Days before the game launched, he reversed course, posted a video with uncle Eli reading a fake play call, and got into the game just in time for release.
Whether Stockton follows a similar arc remains to be seen. Unlike Manning, Stockton isn't a backup waiting his turn — he's the guy. He's been in the game before. He has an established rating and an established profile. The most charitable read is that the paperwork deadline slipped. The least charitable read is that something more deliberate is happening. Neither Stockton nor Haynes has publicly addressed the situation.
Fan Reaction Was Exactly What You'd Expect
Social media responded the way social media tends to when something football-adjacent and slightly bewildering surfaces mid-summer. Fans weren't exactly sympathetic. The consensus ranged from genuine confusion to mild outrage, with a few contributions that felt entirely on-brand for the college football internet.
The critiques essentially boil down to one question nobody has been able to answer: what is the upside? The game pays you. It gives you exposure. It lets fans run 12-for-12 fourth-quarter drives with your digital likeness. It costs nothing and takes minimal effort. The absence of a compelling reason makes the absence itself more frustrating — especially for a fan base that wants nothing more than to run the ball into the end zone with their favorite player on a Tuesday night in August while waiting for fall camp to open.
What Comes Next
College Football 27 launches July 9, with early access for MVP+ subscribers beginning July 2 and Deluxe/Ultimate Edition holders getting in July 6. If Stockton and Haynes opt in before or shortly after launch, EA can patch them into the first post-release roster update — which historically arrives quickly. The window isn't closed.
But there's something a little ironic about a quarterback who's spent the past year making a case for the Heisman Trophy being absent from the one medium where college football fans live out their most optimistic projections. Gunner Stockton led Georgia to an SEC Championship, nearly went 12-for-12 in the fourth quarter of a game he had no business winning, and is the odds-on candidate to be the best quarterback in the country this fall.
For now, at least in one very specific digital sense, he doesn't exist. Georgia fans might have to settle for a created player wearing No. 14 until the paperwork gets sorted.
Here's hoping it does.
Trusted By Programs Across The Country
