There's a chair in college football right now, and it's cursed. You sit in it, you get a nice view of the rest of the country, and then some unranked team you barely circled on the calendar walks over and kicks the legs out.
BYU sat in the No. 2 chair for exactly one week.
Seven days after the Cougars knocked off Notre Dame and climbed to the second spot in the AP poll, they flew across the country to Orlando and lost 39-31 in double overtime to a UCF team that came in hovering around .500. Fans stormed the field at the Bounce House. A backup quarterback accounted for four touchdowns. A roughing-the-kicker flag rewrote the second overtime. And somewhere, the ghost of 2007 smiled.
According to CBS Sports, this is only the second time in the AP poll era that a top-two team has lost to an unranked opponent three weeks in a row. The other time was 2007, the Year of the Upset. We are not approaching that season anymore. We are living in its sequel.
A backup quarterback plays like the main character
The name you need to know is Keyone Jenkins. He's UCF's backup. He did not play like one.
Jenkins threw for 293 yards and three touchdowns, ran for another score and added 35 rushing yards, per CBS Sports and AP. He went 25-of-41, and the ones that mattered seemed to find their target every time. UCF piled up 463 yards on a BYU defense that had looked airtight a week earlier, and the Cougars spent the night missing tackles in open space.
Kalani Sitake didn't hide from that after the game. He told reporters that UCF was "more fundamentally sound," that the Knights "outcoached us," and that he needed "to do a better job coaching" his own team. On the tackling issues, he credited UCF's "great skill in space." It was the postgame of a coach who knew exactly what he'd just watched.
Meanwhile, BYU quarterback Bear Bachmeier threw three touchdowns but completed only about half of his passes, according to CBS. UCF's defense kept shifting looks at him, and by the end Sitake acknowledged the Knights had gotten Bachmeier "a little bit confused."
The end of regulation was a fever dream
If you missed the final seconds of the fourth quarter, I'm sorry, and also I'm not sure I can fully explain them.
With the game tied late, BYU appeared to force a strip-sack on Jenkins to kill UCF's final drive. Replay overturned it: Jenkins' arm was moving forward, so it became an incomplete pass. Worse for BYU, an unsportsmanlike conduct penalty was tacked on, pushing UCF into field goal range, per CBS.
Then the Cougars blocked the attempt. All-American safety Faletau Satuala got a hand on it. The UCF kicker scooped up the loose ball, which briefly looked like it might give the Knights another try, but his helmet came off during the tackle, triggering a mandatory 10-second runoff. Regulation over. Scott Frost was reportedly trying to set up a second kick with a different kicker. Instead, overtime.
That sequence alone would be a top-five weird ending of most seasons. In 2026, it was merely the appetizer.
The flag that flipped double overtime
In the second overtime, UCF stalled and lined up for a 26-yard field goal that put it ahead 34-31, per ESPN. Then the flag came out: roughing the kicker on BYU's Kendal Wall. Three points became first-and-goal from the BYU 4.
Two plays later, Jenkins hit Brousseau for a touchdown, and Tyren Hornes converted the two-point try. 39-31.
Sitake was asked about the call and didn't go full meltdown, but he didn't pretend to agree, either. He said he hadn't received an explanation and that from what he saw, he didn't think it was roughing. "Sometimes the calls work out for us, sometimes they don't," he said, "and that one it didn't."
BYU still had its answer in hand. The Cougars needed a touchdown and a two-point conversion to force a third overtime. They got to the UCF 4. Bachmeier was just short on a throw to Kyle Kasper, and then a string of incompletions ended it, the last a fourth-down pass to Walker Lyons that fell to the turf, according to AP and CBS. The field disappeared under a wave of black and gold.
It was UCF's first win over an AP top-five team in program history, per CBS. For a program that spent years yelling that it belonged at the big table, that's not nothing.
The bigger picture: nobody is safe, and nobody is spotless
Zoom out and Saturday looks less like an upset and more like a pattern.
NCAA.com counted five unranked-over-ranked wins in the week: UCF over BYU, Cincinnati over No. 8 Texas Tech, South Carolina over No. 11 Tennessee on a walk-off field goal, Minnesota over Iowa on another walk-off kick, and Wisconsin's 24-7 beatdown of USC. Texas also took down No. 7 Ole Miss in a ranked-on-ranked thriller. Three undefeated teams fell on the day, leaving only Miami, UCLA and Utah unbeaten, and Utah needed to grind past Houston late at night to stay that way.
Per NCAA.com, it's the first time since the Division I-A/I-AA split in 1978 that three or fewer FBS teams were undefeated through Oct. 24.
For BYU, the damage is real but not fatal. The Cougars are 6-1 and 3-1 in Big 12 play, and Sitake was already pointing forward: "We can't let one loss define us." Playoff math still gives a one-loss Power 4 team plenty of oxygen, and a showdown with Utah still sits on the schedule. Win that, and Orlando becomes a footnote.
But here's the honest takeaway: BYU's résumé took a hit, and so did the idea that any team outside Miami's zip code has this thing figured out. Being ranked No. 2 in 2026 isn't a reward. It's a target with a bye-week countdown.
So who wants the chair next?
Somebody has to be No. 2 when the new poll drops. Ohio State, idle this week and working through its own quarterback questions, is the obvious candidate. History over the last three weeks suggests that whoever gets it should check under the bed, lock the doors and maybe not schedule a road trip against a team with a backup quarterback and nothing to lose.
UCF, meanwhile, gets to be the happiest team in America for a week. Jenkins has a highlight reel. Frost has a signature win. And college football has fresh proof that the parity everyone has been talking about since NIL and the portal reshaped rosters isn't a theory anymore.
It's a weekly event. Set your alarms.
Share this story
C
