Blog / Article

Dave Doeren Owns NC State's Intentional Safety Disaster as the 1,046-1 Fumble at Vanderbilt Refuses to Fade

Dave Doeren Owns NC State's Intentional Safety Disaster as the 1,046-1 Fumble at Vanderbilt Refuses to Fade

C

CFB Team

September 21, 2026

Sponsored by

Snaps Clothing logo

There's a number Dave Doeren will hear for the rest of his career: 1,046-1. According to ESPN, that's how college football teams have done over the last 20 seasons when they had the ball and the lead with 10 seconds left. For two decades the one loss belonged to Michigan's punter against Michigan State in 2015. Now NC State has company in that sentence, and the whole country has seen the clip again and again.

On Monday afternoon, Doeren did the only thing a head coach can do after a loss like that. He took the blame.

"It's a terrible way to end a football game that you controlled," Doeren said. "So there was a lot of pain in that locker room after the game, a lot of anger. I know the fans feel the same way."

Six seconds, a safety and a play that went wrong

Here's how it happened. NC State led Vanderbilt 31-28 in Nashville with six seconds left and the ball at its own 5 on fourth down. The Wolfpack had already survived one scare: safety Brody Barnhardt intercepted freshman Jared Curtis at the NC State 2 with 1:04 left, which looked like the end. Vanderbilt still had two timeouts, so NC State ran three times with backup quarterback Will Wilson, took a delay of game to stop the clock, and chose not to risk a blocked punt.

The call was an intentional safety. It's a well-known way to close out a game: the quarterback rolls out, runs off as much time as he can, then goes down or steps out of the end zone. Give up two points, win by one, go home.

CJ Bailey rolled out. Then, instead of getting down, he started running toward the rush. Three Vanderbilt defenders hit him in the end zone, Miles Capers punched the ball out, and cornerback Cayden Daniels fell on it for a touchdown. The review upheld it and put one second back on the clock. NC State's desperate lateral play on the final snap ended with another Vanderbilt fumble recovery. Final: Vanderbilt 35, NC State 31.

"We talk about every blade of grass on defense, and that's literally every blade of grass," Vanderbilt coach Clark Lea said. He added a line that summed up the day: "We cheated the football gods today and got away with it."

Doeren's accountability math

Saturday's version of Doeren was angry and wanted everyone to remember the other 59 minutes and 59 seconds. "I can't go out there and tackle for guys, and I can't hang onto the ball for guys," he told reporters in Nashville. He described exactly what should have happened: "It's just a play where you roll out and you don't get tackled... then fall on the ground, and protect the football. He got hit, and he didn't protect the football."

Monday's version was more measured, and it spread the blame both ways. Doeren said the team practices the scenario regularly and that Bailey was "trying to get too much time off the clock." Then he said it plainly:

"When a play isn't executed properly, there's two things that are true. The player didn't do what he was coached or trained to do, and the coach didn't do a good enough job training the player to do what he wanted him to do. And both of those things are true."

He repeated the line he'd used Saturday: "CJ takes ownership, I take ownership, (offensive coordinator) Kurt Roper takes ownership, we take ownership." He said he and Bailey have spent time since the game "just talking through" the sequence, "letting him vent and talk, letting me do the same," and added, "He and I love each other."

That matters because Bailey was very good until the last play. He went 25-of-37 for 275 yards and three touchdowns, and NC State's offense controlled the game in brutal heat. The National Weather Service said Nashville hit a record 100 degrees. The Wolfpack ran for 164 yards and were minutes away from their first road win over an SEC opponent since 1977. Instead Vanderbilt, which trailed 17-0 in the first half and 24-7 in the third quarter, matched its biggest comeback win since beating Ole Miss in 2012. The fumble return was the only time the Commodores led all game.

The 2016 ghost Doeren brought up

Asked whether anything compares, Doeren went back 10 years to a loss at Clemson in 2016, when NC State missed a short field goal at the end of regulation and lost in overtime to a team that went on to win the national title. NC State was 4-1 before that game. It then lost four straight and finished 7-6.

"That devastated our locker room for a long period of time," Doeren said. "I'm not going to let that happen."

That's the real issue. The Wolfpack are 1-2, and Doeren is in his 14th season as the winningest coach in program history, now facing the toughest rebuilding week of his tenure. Appalachian State comes to Carter-Finley on Saturday night. The question now is whether a team that knows it should be 2-1 can keep from turning bitter.

"You never sleep as a coach after a tough loss, particularly a loss like that when you feel like you were the better team," Doeren said.

Why this blunder will follow NC State

Every college football season has a few moments that turn into permanent highlights. The Michigan punt in 2015 is one. The Music City Miracle is another. This fumble joins that group, and not for anything NC State wanted. It's a lesson every coach will now use in practice: when you're taking a safety, get down.

The frustrating part for NC State fans is that the decision itself was reasonable. Taking the safety rather than punting from your own 5 is standard. The plan was fine. It fell apart in the 2 or 3 seconds when a competitive quarterback tried to make one more play he didn't need to make. Doeren knows that. That's why he blamed himself along with Bailey on Monday.

His job now isn't to explain the play. Everyone has already watched it a hundred times. His job is to make sure it doesn't sink the season the way that Clemson loss did in 2016. NC State will be the 1,046-1 team permanently. The rest of the season will decide whether that's the only thing people remember about 2026.

There's a number Dave Doeren will hear for the rest of his career: 1,046-1. According to ESPN, that's how college football teams have done over the last 20 seasons when they had the ball and the lead with 10 seconds left. For two decades the one loss belonged to Michigan's punter against Michigan State in 2015. Now NC State has company in that sentence, and the whole country has seen the clip again and again.

On Monday afternoon, Doeren did the only thing a head coach can do after a loss like that. He took the blame.

"It's a terrible way to end a football game that you controlled," Doeren said. "So there was a lot of pain in that locker room after the game, a lot of anger. I know the fans feel the same way."

Six seconds, a safety and a play that went wrong

Here's how it happened. NC State led Vanderbilt 31-28 in Nashville with six seconds left and the ball at its own 5 on fourth down. The Wolfpack had already survived one scare: safety Brody Barnhardt intercepted freshman Jared Curtis at the NC State 2 with 1:04 left, which looked like the end. Vanderbilt still had two timeouts, so NC State ran three times with backup quarterback Will Wilson, took a delay of game to stop the clock, and chose not to risk a blocked punt.

The call was an intentional safety. It's a well-known way to close out a game: the quarterback rolls out, runs off as much time as he can, then goes down or steps out of the end zone. Give up two points, win by one, go home.

CJ Bailey rolled out. Then, instead of getting down, he started running toward the rush. Three Vanderbilt defenders hit him in the end zone, Miles Capers punched the ball out, and cornerback Cayden Daniels fell on it for a touchdown. The review upheld it and put one second back on the clock. NC State's desperate lateral play on the final snap ended with another Vanderbilt fumble recovery. Final: Vanderbilt 35, NC State 31.

"We talk about every blade of grass on defense, and that's literally every blade of grass," Vanderbilt coach Clark Lea said. He added a line that summed up the day: "We cheated the football gods today and got away with it."

Doeren's accountability math

Saturday's version of Doeren was angry and wanted everyone to remember the other 59 minutes and 59 seconds. "I can't go out there and tackle for guys, and I can't hang onto the ball for guys," he told reporters in Nashville. He described exactly what should have happened: "It's just a play where you roll out and you don't get tackled... then fall on the ground, and protect the football. He got hit, and he didn't protect the football."

Monday's version was more measured, and it spread the blame both ways. Doeren said the team practices the scenario regularly and that Bailey was "trying to get too much time off the clock." Then he said it plainly:

"When a play isn't executed properly, there's two things that are true. The player didn't do what he was coached or trained to do, and the coach didn't do a good enough job training the player to do what he wanted him to do. And both of those things are true."

He repeated the line he'd used Saturday: "CJ takes ownership, I take ownership, (offensive coordinator) Kurt Roper takes ownership, we take ownership." He said he and Bailey have spent time since the game "just talking through" the sequence, "letting him vent and talk, letting me do the same," and added, "He and I love each other."

That matters because Bailey was very good until the last play. He went 25-of-37 for 275 yards and three touchdowns, and NC State's offense controlled the game in brutal heat. The National Weather Service said Nashville hit a record 100 degrees. The Wolfpack ran for 164 yards and were minutes away from their first road win over an SEC opponent since 1977. Instead Vanderbilt, which trailed 17-0 in the first half and 24-7 in the third quarter, matched its biggest comeback win since beating Ole Miss in 2012. The fumble return was the only time the Commodores led all game.

The 2016 ghost Doeren brought up

Asked whether anything compares, Doeren went back 10 years to a loss at Clemson in 2016, when NC State missed a short field goal at the end of regulation and lost in overtime to a team that went on to win the national title. NC State was 4-1 before that game. It then lost four straight and finished 7-6.

"That devastated our locker room for a long period of time," Doeren said. "I'm not going to let that happen."

That's the real issue. The Wolfpack are 1-2, and Doeren is in his 14th season as the winningest coach in program history, now facing the toughest rebuilding week of his tenure. Appalachian State comes to Carter-Finley on Saturday night. The question now is whether a team that knows it should be 2-1 can keep from turning bitter.

"You never sleep as a coach after a tough loss, particularly a loss like that when you feel like you were the better team," Doeren said.

Why this blunder will follow NC State

Every college football season has a few moments that turn into permanent highlights. The Michigan punt in 2015 is one. The Music City Miracle is another. This fumble joins that group, and not for anything NC State wanted. It's a lesson every coach will now use in practice: when you're taking a safety, get down.

The frustrating part for NC State fans is that the decision itself was reasonable. Taking the safety rather than punting from your own 5 is standard. The plan was fine. It fell apart in the 2 or 3 seconds when a competitive quarterback tried to make one more play he didn't need to make. Doeren knows that. That's why he blamed himself along with Bailey on Monday.

His job now isn't to explain the play. Everyone has already watched it a hundred times. His job is to make sure it doesn't sink the season the way that Clemson loss did in 2016. NC State will be the 1,046-1 team permanently. The rest of the season will decide whether that's the only thing people remember about 2026.

Share this story

C

CFB Team
CFB Team

The most trusted college football team.

The most trusted college football team.

Keep Reading

Never Miss The Next Alert

Real-time college football news, NIL moves, and recruiting intel — delivered the moment it breaks.

Keep Reading

Never Miss The Next Alert

Real-time college football news, NIL moves, and recruiting intel — delivered the moment it breaks.

Coast To Coast

Trusted By Programs Across The Country

Coast To Coast

Trusted By Programs Across The Country